Employee Incentive Schemes

Herrington Carmichael is a full service law firm offering legal advice to UK and international businesses as well as individuals and families.
/
/
/
Employee Incentive Schemes

In the UK, implementation of an employee incentive scheme provides employees with the option to acquire shares in their employer company (or a member of its group).

Such schemes can therefore be useful in incentivising performance and aligning employees’ interests with the shareholders and management team.

On the grant of a share option scheme, the option holder will be granted the right to acquire shares in the company at a pre-determined price in the future. The option holder will not actually acquire the shares under option until the option is exercised – which can be dependent on factors such as satisfying certain performance criteria, and/or a future sale of the company.

At the point the option is exercised, the option holder will become a shareholder of the company.

A share scheme is a way of founders sharing equity with employees. Equity in a company means ownership – anyone who holds shares in a company owns part of the company (and therefore its assets).

There are many different forms of share scheme, but they all work in one of two ways:

Equity now – employees are given actual shares in the company now

Equity later – employees are granted an option which gives them a right to purchase shares in the company at a certain point in the future (at an agreed price)

An EMI scheme provides selected employees with the option to acquire shares in your company in the future. You will have discretion to decide who participates, and the scheme can be tailored to different employees' role, seniority, and the value they bring to the business.

If required, the options can be subject to certain exercise conditions. This means that employees will be motivated to work hard, to ensure that the conditions are satisfied, and they will therefore be able to exercise their options. Typical EMI schemes include conditions relating to an exit of the company, time, and performance criteria.

To be able to grant EMI options, there are qualifying criteria that both the company and the proposed option holder must satisfy. In relation to the company, the conditions relate to matters such as the assets of the company, the number of employees, and trading activities. In relation to the employee, the conditions relate to their working patterns.

As EMI schemes are approved by HMRC, the tax treatment for both the company and the employee is favourable.

An LTIP is an employee incentive arrangement where participators' performance is measured over a period of time.

LTIPS usually involve participation by senior executives, and the incentive usually involves the provision of 'free shares' on the satisfaction of certain performance conditions over a period of time.

LTIPs are a useful tool in aligning interests of employees who are able to influence the success of the company.

Types of Long Term Incentive Plan

There are several kinds of awards that can be made under an Long Term Incentive Plan (LTIP), which are sometimes referred to as Performance Share Plans.

These include:

  • nil-cost options
  • conditional share awards
  • share appreciation rights
  • restricted shares.

The awards typically take the form of free shares being offered when certain conditions have been achieved.

LTIPs generally promote long-term staff retention, as multi-year vesting periods can ensure that participants remain with the company throughout the duration of the award.

A Company Share Option Plan (CSOP) scheme provides employees with an option to acquire shares in the company at a later date.

To qualify to grant CSOP options, the company must meet certain criteria. Provided the criteria are satisfied, favourable tax treatment will apply for both the company and the employees who are part of the scheme.

You have discretion to decide who will participate in the scheme, and the exercise of shares under CSOPs can also be subject to the satisfaction of certain performance conditions if required.

CSOPs are approved by HMRC, and therefore attract favourable tax treatment for both the company and the employee provided certain qualifying conditions are satisfied.

Growth Share Schemes are strategic initiatives that can be used to incentivise key employees by rewarding them in line with future business growth.

These types of incentives should be considered if it is anticipated that your company will achieve substantial growth in the future.

Growth shares allow the holders to benefit only from the growth in value of the company from the time the shares are awarded, which can motivate employees to achieve growth for the company.

Growth Shares typically amplify in value with the company's success, hurdle shares trigger additional benefits upon achieving performance targets and flowering shares escalate rewards tied to predefined milestones in the business.

Employee Share schemes (EMI Schemes) can be equally, if not more, beneficial to startups with few employees than to large companies with many employees.

Why should startups offer equity?

Key contact

Yavan-Brar-PNG
Yavan Brar
Chief Executive Officer

What our clients say about us

We were very happy with our service. Being first-time buyers and brand new to the property world, Annari & Mary-Jayne relieved all of our worries and made our journey very stress-free and relatively easy. Thank you.

We received excellent support in reviewing and modifying our Wills to our latest needs. The communication has always been straightforward and very effective and we achieved the objectives we set at the beginning of the process. Strong expertise and legal knowledge have been key to the successful completion.

It was a very straightforward process & Charlotte explained everything clearly to us in a very friendly way & answered any queries we had. It was a pleasure to have her deal with this matter, and I would certainly come to your firm of solicitors on that basis. Thank you so much.

Paul provided calm, helpful, constructive and thorough advice on my matter and I will be in touch again to progress.

Aadil has been representing my son through a very challenging child custody/recovery case. His help and knowledge has been fantastic. He went above and beyond working on his day off too make sure court papers were delivered on time. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Aadil.

I just wanted to write a huge thank you for all your help and support during my recent divorce proceedings There were times when it seemed things would never get resolved but thankfully with your guidance everything went relatively smoothly in the end.

Annari is an excellent Solicitor. We have always used her services for all of our property conveyancing jobs. She is a valuable asset to your company.

We had the pleasure of working with Annari on buying our very first house. We would like to take this opportunity to let you know how efficient Annari was throughout the entire process. Annari really helped to make buying our first home an easy process! She absolutely went above and beyond her call of duty.

The service we received was exceptional. We were always updated and Annari would answer any questions I had immediately. Keep doing what you do Annari. Thank you so much for everything, and Amy too.

Thanks again, we’ve always felt in good hands. It is for this reason we’d highly recommend Herrington Carmichael and especially Annari.

Annari is an excellent Solicitor. We have always used her services for all of our property conveyancing jobs. She is a valuable asset to your company.

We had the pleasure of working with Annari on buying our very first house. We would like to take this opportunity to let you know how efficient Annari was throughout the enitre process. Annari really helped to make buying our first home an easy process! She absolutely went above and beyond her call of duty.

Both Holly Bray & Jessica Brooke were fantastic from start to finish on the purchase of my new build property. Nothing was an issues for them and I didn’t need to chase them for anything at all. I was kept well informed all the way through the process to completion and everything was dealt with in a very pleasant and professional manner. I would happily recommend Herrington Carmichael to anyone looking for a conveyancer for the purchase of their property. 5 stars.

From start to finish Herrington Carmichael staff have been excellent. Communication has been second to none and cannot fault them for everything. Would not hesitate to recommend them to anyone looking for a reliable, friendly and very efficient service.

Being first time buyer, Holly was very helpful in explaining the process and expediting all the things. Thank you very much for quick process.

Professional service, nice communication, I would have no hesitation in recommending and will be using them again in the near future.

They were super helpful, very efficient and had timely communication. I would use them again and recommend them to friends and family.

Laura and Amy have both been fantastic throughout the whole process. Both were very patient with any questions we had. Everything was made easy for us, making our first house purchase painless and enjoyable. We will certainly be using your company again. Thank you all so much.

Madelyn was always helpful, kind & supportive throughout.

Madelyn Wellstead is a fantastic Senior Apprentice Solicitor who worked on a family law case involving myself and my son. During her time working on my case she was extremely professional and supportive throughout. My case was a very complex case and had alot of ups and downs but Madelyn at all times kept Me informed and up to date. I would highly recommend her as very competent and very knowledgeable and an over all very nice decent person.

Over the past few months Nicole Miller, a Legal Director in Herrington Carmichael’s Private Wealth and Inheritance Department, has provided outstanding service in creating a trust for our family. From the outset, Nicole was professional, knowledgeable, and incredibly reassuring, guiding us through what could have been a complex process with clarity and patience. She took the time to understand our circumstances fully and explained everything in straightforward terms, ensuring we felt confident at every stage.

Nicole’s expertise, attention to detail, and responsive communication gave us complete peace of mind. She handled our matter with both precision and genuine care, making us feel that our family’s interests were truly valued. We are extremely grateful for her support and would wholeheartedly recommend her to anyone seeking expert and compassionate private wealth advice.

Considering the mess I was in when I first met you, I’ve managed to stay intact and that’s mostly down to your advice keeping me on the straight and narrow. For that I will always be grateful.

I just wanted to write a huge thank you for all your help and support during my recent divorce proceedings. There were times when it seemed things would never get resolved but thankfully with your guidance everything went relatively smoothly in the end.

What a joy to deal with a personable, on the ball and helpful individual! You do your organisation a great service helping clients now during Covid as you are, and I would not think twice about using your services in the future. Thank you for being you and going the extra mile!

Throughout the whole process, Roisin acted quickly on all aspects, was easy to get hold of, responded with pace and communicated fantastically, always finding effective ways to translate complex legal jargon into layman’s terms. Roisin is clearly operates at the top-end of her profession and as such, is someone I would wholeheartedly recommend.

I opted to use Roisin at Herrington-Carmichael to support with my purchase & sale as a result of her personable manner. Roisin made me feel that she had my best interests at heart and that I wouldn’t be just another transaction. Roisin more than lived up to my first impression, in fact I attribute the successful completion of my sale and purchase – which all but fell-through at the eleventh hour – to her tenacity, expertise and willingness to go above and beyond.

It’s been a pleasure working with you on my new venture. Your tenacious professional approach to the task in hand, has been refreshingly inspiring to say the least.

Sarah and her team have made this difficult time much better by the way they dealt with my case. The process was straightforward and i would use Sarah again without hesitation.

Sarah was very thorough, extremely knowledgeable but remained personable throughout making me feel at ease when needed.

Thank you again for all your help with what I have been through over the last year and a half. You gave me the confidence and belief to get through what has been the toughest time in my life. (You’ve got this) Thank you.

I can't thank Aadil and Madelyn enough for what they did for me in such a short space of time. I had previously used Aadil and didn't hesitate to contact him again regarding the issue I had.

Aadil has been representing my son through a very challenging child custody/recovery case. His help and knowledge has been fantastic. He went above and beyond working on his day off to make sure court papers were delivered on time. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Aadil.

I can honestly say that i have never received such good service from a solicitor ( and I’ve bought and sold many houses!!) as I have from Leo. He has been so professional, responsive and pro-active - it has made a huge difference to us during this process. I do hope that you recognise him for such good service and advice. Many thanks to all.

I have had the pleasure of working with Liz on several complex property purchases, including overseas based companies and legal opinions, commercial leases analysis, building contracts assignments and collateral warranties. On each occasion, Liz has acted promptly, kept me appraised of the progress and demonstrated excellent commercial awareness and professionalism in dealing with client’s solicitors, in order to meet tight completion deadlines. I have no hesitation in recommending Liz for all property related legal matters.

I also would like to specifically recognise Rachel Duncan, Partner Real Estate, for her outstanding support. Her expertise in real estate, particularly within the housing sector, has been exceptional. She provided clear, pragmatic advice on a complex matter, helping us navigate potential disputes and avoid unnecessary costs.....Her practical, solution-focused approach, combined with her responsiveness and professionalism, made a significant difference. She is a real asset to the firm.

The property team have been diligent, timely and highly responsive. This has allowed us to focus on our developments knowing that the matter is in capable hands.

I am delighted with the level of service and advice I got from Rachel. I felt in a safe pair of hands which took the stress out of negotiating the lease with our new landlord. It allowed me to focus on the fit out of our larger office.

She has always been extremely knowledgeable and professional, providing fantastic support and skill across all property transactions.

Thanks for all your help with the finalising the renewal lease for our tenant company in Ottershaw. You ensured that the process went smoothly and we were able to discuss various aspects of the renewal and decide which factors were relevant to this transaction and which ones were optional.

We used Herrington Carmichael to assist with a neighbour dispute regarding trespassing. With Daniel’s support, we were able to achieve our desired outcome in a timely manner. Daniel was approachable, clear in his communication and instructions, and provided us with well-informed advice on the best options for resolution. All communication was transparent, and any costs incurred were clearly explained in advance before work was undertaken. We would not hesitate to use Herrington Carmichael again for any future legal services and would definitely recommend them to others.

Professional, informative and would recommend.

Thank you so much, Thomas, for your hard work, persistence and patience throughout the process of getting the required documentation over the line by the deadline. It certainly was a challenging and frustrating time with quite a few obstacles thrown in our way, but your determination got us there.

I would love to start by saying our experience with Herrington Carmichael has been amazing from start to finish, and I would highly recommend the firm. Thomas Joucan was absolutely brilliant, and I couldn’t be any happier with his professionalism and absolute integrity, with such speedy replies and getting all aspects of our purchase and sale tied in seamlessly. Without doubt a brilliant, honest and professional solicitor with a big future ahead.

Tim Hardesty is our residential development lawyer. He is a good lawyer and has offered very sound advice. He is able to provide advice on land purchasing, planning, SDLT and issues that impact on the land buying process. What I like about Tim is that he doesn’t use legal jargon and has a common-sense approach to land buying. He is proactive in getting deals done and, importantly from my perspective, doesn’t hold deals up over unimportant legal points. He is also very personable, and well known and liked by other professionals.

We've had a great experience with Herrington Carmichael when buying our first house! All of this was completely new to us and they made sure the process was smooth and easy! Lisa has been amazing and was a recommendation from some other family members who have used her in the past. Thanks again.

I have thoroughly enjoyed working with you. Your professional advice, responsiveness and straightforward approach have been invaluable.

I recently had the pleasure of working with Herrington Carmichael and I can't express how grateful I am for their support and expertise. From our very first interaction, they made me feel valued and understood my needs. Their professionalism and attention to detail were evident in every step of the process. The team was always available to answer my questions and provided clear explanations of the legal jargon, which made everything much more manageable. They navigated the complexities of my purchase with such skill and care, ensuring that I was informed and comfortable at every stage. It was clear that they were committed to achieving the quick turn around from agreement to completion, and their hard work truly made a difference. I could not have asked for a better solicitors in what could have been a stressful experience. I highly recommend Herrington Carmichael to anyone in need of legal services. Their dedication and proficiency are unparalleled, and I am incredibly thankful for the support they provided. Thank you for making this journey so positive!

It was a pleasure working with Liz and Hannah on this transaction, securing crucial funding for an iconic hotel in South Devon. The communication and commercial guidance from Liz, Hannah and the wider Herrington Carmichael team was first rate throughout. I would not hesitate in recommending them for future transactions and look forward to working with the team again soon.

Dealing with Hannah was very easy. She was very helpful and professional.

Absolutely spot on - well done. I cannot be more thankful to all of you for being extremely helpful and professional right from day one. Special thanks to Hannah for getting everything sorted out at the last minute. Thank you for the excellent service and helping us out at every stage of our first house purchase. You will always be remembered!

Insights

Get valuable insights from our articles.

Advising-a-software-development-company-on-Growth-Share-Scheme-Implementation
The Herrington Carmichael corporate team has advised the founder of a business and domestic software development company on the implementation…
Nurses assisting elderly people at retirement home
HC successfully advised Kenmore Group on its acquisition of the business and assets comprising Hamilton Park Nursing Home from Sentimental…
Business partnership meeting in office
Herrington Carmichael successfully advised Cennox Group, a global group expanding its portfolio of innovative companies within the technology, security and…

Meet our experts

Dedicated professionals ready to assist you.

Yavan-Brar-PNG
Chief Executive Officer
Sophie Protheroe PNG
Senior Solicitor

Frequently Asked Questions

Find answers to your most pressing questions about our services and processes.

There are many benefits associated with shared employee ownership for businesses. The most common reasons we see employers wanting to set up schemes include:

  • Recruitment of top talent, particularly when the recruitment market is tough
  • Retention of the best talent
  • Creation of an ownership culture amongst employees
  • To motivate employees to improve their performance and productivity
  • Reward employees (similar to a cash bonus scheme)
  • To keep up with competitor firms in the industry

There are various types of scheme, some of which are suited to larger companies and some more suited to small companies or start-ups with only two or three founders. Four of the available schemes are “approved” by HMRC which means that they are tax-efficient for the employees receiving shares/options. These are:

  • Enterprise Management Incentives (EMIs)
  • Company Share Option Plans (CSOPs)
  • Share Incentive Plans (SIPs)
  • Save As You Earn (SAYE)

Other schemes are “unapproved” and are potentially not as tax-efficient. These include:

  • Growth shares
  • Unapproved share options
  • Nil paid shares

The best share scheme for a business will depend on its size, industry, employees and motivations for implementing a scheme. Some examples of recent share schemes we have helped clients with include:

Company 1: start-up business where the founder shareholder brought in an employee who he wanted to motivate to grow the business with the aim of a sale in 8-10 years.

Company 2: a founder shareholder wanted to reduce his shareholding over time for personal tax planning reasons and to pass on ownership to employees.

Company 3: company had an existing EMI scheme exercisable by employees on a sale of the company.

Company 4: company currently valued at £11m wanted to motivate its management team to participate in the future growth of the business.

EMIs are most commonly implemented by entrepreneurial companies of small to medium size. To qualify companies must meet certain criteria. They must:

  • Be independent, therefore not a 51% subsidiary of another company and any subsidiaries your company may have must also qualify
  • Carry on a “qualifying trade” – certain trades are excluded, for example banking, insurance, property development, farming and hotel management
  • Have fewer than 250 full time employees
  • Have gross assets of less than £30m
  • Be permanently established in the UK

EMIs are relatively simple schemes to implement and are, in turn, easy for the employees concerned to understand.

EMIs are HMRC ‘approved’, meaning that they receive favourable tax treatment is in relation to both the company and employees.

Companies benefit from a Corporation Tax deduction, given in the accounting year in which the options are exercised, equal to the gain made by the employee.

Implementing a share scheme in the early stages of a company’s growth can assist with:

  1. Recruitment & retention – employees will be inclined to stay with the company long term to satisfy the conditions required to exercise their option
  2. Improved performance – employees will be motivated by their ability to participate in profits as the company grows
  3. Driving value – the possibility of acquiring shares will align the incentives of employees and founders to increase the company’s growth and profits

There is a typical “lawyer’s answer” to this question, which is – it depends! The scheme that is best suited to a company depends on the founders’ motivations, which could range from tax effectiveness, affordability or security for their own interests.

This is a decision for the founders of the business to make and will depend on how much equity they want to retain for the future. Typically, we see smaller businesses set an option pool of between 10-20%.